Hello President Devereaux, my name is Sam Dylan. I am a student leader in many forms on campus, but today I am coming to you as the chair of the Student Judicial Board for the Code of Conduct. For those not aware, the college has been in the process of updating the Student Code of Conduct Policy over the past two semesters. These updates are being made because many students have expressed concerns about the Code of Conduct’s effectiveness and accuracy. The student judicial board was formed (reestablished) to have student voices in the accountability process. The students who serve on the appeals board (SGA President Max Ravnitzky ‘28 and Vice President Azeezah Azeez ‘28) serve a similar role in the accountability process, to have student voices in the decisions that affect student outcomes. Last week, I got to discuss with the administration the changes that are being made to the policy. These changes have gone to the College’s policy committee and are on their way to the cabinet, and after approval from the cabinet, the policy will be established as college law.
One of the most concerning changes to the policy is around the appeals board. Under the proposed policy, only appeals cases that have very serious sanctions (i.e expulsion or suspension) will go to the appeals board. All other appeals (even if the reason for appeal or case is serious) will be dealt with by an appellate officer (Vice President of Student Affairs Aarika Camp, Dean of Students Justin Smith, or their designee). The vast majority of cases that the Code of Conduct Office sees would not meet the requirements to see an appeals board. This would mean that nearly all appeal cases will be handled by administration from the same office you are appealing against. I believe that all students should have the opportunity to have their case heard by an appeals board regardless of the severity of punishment.
Another concern I have regarding changes to the policy is how students are appointed to the Student Judicial Board. With the proposed changes, the Student Affairs staff would
collaborate with the Student Government Association, but Student Affairs have final say in who is on the board. I personally believe that this leaves the opportunity for any student who has argued against the way accountability is addressed on campus to be much less likely to be appointed as a member of the board. Students’ goal behind the Judicial Board is to have opinions other than administrators in the accountability process.
Similarly, the way the policy is written, it is possible for the Judicial Board to not be composed of a student majority. I have been told that ideally that would not happen and that they would want the board to be composed of a student majority. However, it is concerning that it is even possible to not have a student majority. For further context on why this decision is a bad idea, these changes are coming at a time when many students have expressed to me that they do not feel comfortable going to administration because they have been “warned” that if they continue to speak about how Goucher handles accountability, it could result in a conduct violation. To be clear, what I have been made aware of is administration outside of the Student Affairs office. However, it is still concerning that students have been warned with conduct violations regardless of which office it is coming from.
President Devereaux, I want to be very clear in my next statement.
The accountability process should be in place to support students, not administrators. It is a poor decision to move even more power in the accountability process to the administration when students are expressing that they don’t feel comfortable with many administrators. These changes make the Student Judicial Board and Student members on the Appeals Board a performative gesture to make the College and the Code of Conduct process look better.
President Devereaux, my question is this.
How can students feel comfortable and confident in utilizing the accountability process when student power and voice have been reduced in this process, power has been siloed into one office, and students are “warned” with conduct violations if they speak out against college accountability procedures?
President Devereaux, will you support moving the cabinet vote of approval for this policy until after students are able to see and provide feedback on the concrete changes made?
By Sam Dylan ’27







Be First to Comment